Columbia or Cleveland Welding frame

[KZ1000]

I have to trade a boys frame for 2 bikes, What "frame only" is more valuable to keep, a mid 1940's Cleveland Welding, or a 1957 Columbia, Pics enclosed, but I am trading frame only, Rick

 

[skoda]

I would keep that first (green) bike in one piece, that looks pretty unique, don't know much about value on either count but the Columbia probalby isn't worth a whole lot without the tank.

 

[Unkle Krusty]

Does the 3 speed Dana transmission work?

 

[OUTLAW]

find another frame to trade. i'd keep the two ya got. what are you getting in return?

Outlaw 8)

 

[KZ1000]

These are the 2 I get, I need to give him a mens frame with a double bar, Rick

 

[Rodland]

I don't see a parts bike in the bunch! Find another frame to trade.

 

[Mr. Farrell]

i would keep the columbia. the one youre getting is pretty similar to the cleveland... so why end up with two of the same?

i dunno about the value though.