Discussion in 'BUILD OFF 14 DISCUSSION' started by MazdaFlyer, Jan 27, 2019.
Most of the Europeans on this forum felt a little pain while reading that
We're playing for monopoly money and the online camaraderie in these build-off's, right? I'd be hesitant to discourage any of the "really skilled builders" from participating, as their spectacular work really makes these build-off's special. I'm not a spit and polish guy, because I don't polish rust, but I don't do much more than careful assembly of what I think are cool parts. Those artisans amongst us who craft and engineer such unique bicycles should at least get the bragging rights that come with the most votes. Not everyone got a trophy where I grew up.
You are missing my point.
I’m not trying discourage any really skilled scratch custom builders from participating. I would like to see some of spit and polish folks as well as the doodad assembly folks, continue to participate.
Having the two pre-mentioned classes allows that to happen which ought to draw more entries. In no way does that grant everyone a trophy, the bike you build is ultimately your trophy.
This is a Rat Rod Bikes forum, everyone has their own definition of what a rat rod bike is.
I suppose this last comment is a No-No, but what I continue to see built are Restoration Bikes, Rat Rod Bikes and Custom/Kustom Bikes in the summer Build Off.
I’m good with a no frame modifications class and frame modifications class.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I'm in no matter what the rules are. I've got a cool frame, a pile of parts and a vision of what I want to build. I would build this bike regardless, but the build offs are great because you get to see what everyone else is creating and you get lots of good ideas from other peoples builds that you may not have thought of, and lots more creative input on your own bike since everyone is watching. If a handful of people end up voting for my bike at the end it's icing on the cake.
Hey Nick I just saw this post, I’ve got a pretty cool AMF frame and fork I could donate, I’ve built it up a few different ways and never been happy with it, it’s hanging from a hook in the ceiling right now , let me know this is what it looked like before I stole the fork, wheels and rack for other projects
Thanks for the offer Joel! I’ll
Keep it on the back burner, keeping my eyes peeled for an old CWC like I used to have and regret selling. Even been looking for swap meets, seems like no more Dudley meets??
two weekends from now
Always enjoy an @idiotboy build, Joel! Shooting for another OddJob award......?
What's a frame mod? Just wondering where the line in the sand is drawn. I don't personally consider these frame mods while technically they might be...
Shaving brackets off
Adding braze ons
Drilling for internal cables
Cold setting frames
Spreading seat/chain stays or dimpling
Are any of the above considered enough of a frame mod as to put one in the Frame Mod class? Just curious.
I'm remembering now why I ended up changing this over to anything goes.
Maybe the split should be...factory frames in one category and scratch built frames in another.
Man, didn't mean to make things complicated. Just looking for clarification, I'll happily go by whatever rules are laid out. I'm not one to piss and moan about trivial things. Most important is friendly and fun, I'm the not the Dude that's going to rain on anybody's parade. Keep it stock frame and mod frame classes, that seems to be well recieved, at least on this thread it got a lot of positive input. I was over thinking things like I tend to do...
You're not making things difficult. You just reminded me of all of the questions that folks tend to ask about the classes we had run in the past. I think it would be good to split them up by factory frame and scratch built frame. That way if someone wanted to make minor modifications to a factory frame it wouldn't be a big deal.
Define "minor" Here is an old "factory frame" build.
Just messing with you Steve. I always thought the old rule of no welding mods was pretty simple for the first 8 or 9 build offs.
...What if a minor built a frame from scratch?
Maybe the minors on the forum should decide which Mods on the forum should decide what is minor mods.
It's all so confusing.
The rule should be that any frame mods can ONLY be done by minors!
In my best Tennessee Ernie Ford...
I was born one mornin' when the sun didn't shine.
I picked up m'shovel and walked to the mine...
So are you suggesting that only minor miners can do minor mods?
♫ You load sixteen tons, what do you get? ♫ --FILTHY!
Separate names with a comma.